Contingent
vs. Primary Beneficiary:
Why You Need a Back-Up Recipient, How to Choose, and More

Notary public in office signing document

What's the Difference Between Primary and Contingent Beneficiary Designations?

 

Often mentioned during conversations about life insurance policies, retirement accounts, and other financial instruments, primary and contingent beneficiaries refer to individuals, entities, or organizations that can expect to receive the benefits or proceeds upon the death of the policyholder or account holder.

What is a Contingent Beneficiary Designation?

The contingent beneficiary, also called the secondary beneficiary or backup recipient, is next in line to receive any benefits from an existing life insurance policy when the primary beneficiary is unable to do so. In many instances, the contingent beneficiary comes forward when the primary beneficiary predeceases the policyholder or is otherwise disqualified from receiving the benefits.

Naming a primary or contingent beneficiary provides a clear succession plan if the primary beneficiary cannot receive the benefits. As with primary beneficiaries, multiple contingent beneficiaries can be named for a death benefit from life insurance. The policyholder may also specify the percentage distribution of life insurance proceeds among multiple primary beneficiaries and secondary beneficiaries.

The Difference Between Primary and Contingent Beneficiary Designations

The primary beneficiary is the first person or entity in line to receive the death benefits or proceeds from the policy, financial account, or retirement account upon the death of the policyholder or account holder. If the primary beneficiary is alive and eligible to receive the benefits, they will be the recipient. The primary beneficiary designation takes precedence over the contingent beneficiary.

Can the Same Person be a Primary and Contingent Beneficiary?

Naming the same person as both the primary and contingent beneficiary may seem like a good way to simplify the process if the primary beneficiary is likely to be available to receive the benefits upon the policyholder’s passing. However, designating an individual as both the primary and contingent beneficiary can be a mistake. Given that the contingent beneficiary serves as a backup, it is crucial to avoid designating the same person for both roles during estate planning.

Signing testament. Senior man at the table writes on paper. Financial difficulties.

Common Examples Of Primary And Contingent Beneficiaries

Choosing beneficiaries not only involves financial considerations but also emotional and intangible factors. It would largely depend on the policyholder’s specific circumstances, relationships, and financial goals.

Here are examples of primary and contingent beneficiaries to help illustrate various scenarios:

  • Primary Beneficiary: Spouse
    • The policyholder may choose their spouse as the primary beneficiary to ensure financial support for the surviving spouse in the event of the policyholder’s death.
  • Contingent Beneficiary: Children (equally)
    • If the spouse is unable to receive the benefits, the policyholder may designate their children as contingent beneficiaries, ensuring that the death benefit goes to the next generation.
  • Primary Beneficiary: Aging Parents
    • A single policyholder with dependent aging parents may choose to designate them as the primary beneficiaries to provide financial support for their care.
  • Contingent Beneficiary: Siblings
    • If the parents are unable to receive the benefits, the policyholder may designate their siblings as contingent beneficiaries.
  • Primary Beneficiary: Charitable Organization
    • A policyholder with philanthropic goals may choose a charitable organization as the primary beneficiary to support a cause they care about.
  • Contingent Beneficiary: Nieces/Nephews (equally)
    • If the charitable organization cannot receive the benefits, the policyholder may designate their nieces and nephews as contingent beneficiaries.
  • Primary Beneficiary: Current Spouse
    • The policyholder may choose their current spouse as the primary beneficiary for immediate financial support.
  • Contingent Beneficiary: Children from Previous Marriage (equally)
    • In case the current spouse is unable to receive the benefits, the policyholder may designate their children from a previous marriage as contingent beneficiaries to ensure they receive a share.
  • Primary Beneficiary: Business Partner(s)
    • In a business context, a policyholder may designate their business partner(s) as the primary beneficiaries to provide financial support for the business in the event of the policyholder’s death.
  • Contingent Beneficiary: Family Trust
    • If the business partners cannot receive the benefits, the policyholder may designate a family trust as the contingent beneficiary, which can then distribute the benefits according to the terms of the trust.
  • Primary Beneficiary: Sibling
    • A policyholder without dependents may choose a sibling as the primary beneficiary to provide financial support for a close family member.
  • Contingent Beneficiary: Favorite Charity
    • If the sibling is unable to receive the benefits, the policyholder may designate their favorite charitable organization as the contingent beneficiary.

These examples are illustrative, and the choice of beneficiaries is a personal decision. The policyholder needs to consider their unique circumstances, relationships, and financial goals when making these designations.


How to Choose Beneficiaries for Your Life Insurance Policy

Designating beneficiaries during estate planning is a crucial decision that requires careful consideration. First, clarify the purpose of your life insurance policy or estate plan. Whether it’s to provide financial support for your family, pay off debts, cover funeral expenses, or support charitable causes, understanding your goals will influence your choice of beneficiaries.

Consider individuals who depend on your financial support or whom you wish to provide for in the event of your passing. This may include spouses, children, parents, or other family members. Moreover, evaluate the financial dependence of potential beneficiaries.

Choose persons or entities whose financial well-being would be significantly impacted by your death. If you have charitable interests, consider naming charitable organizations or foundations as beneficiaries. This allows you to contribute to causes you care about even after your passing.

Naming Minors as Beneficiaries

Minor children are not legally allowed to directly receive substantial assets. In most instances, it is necessary to designate a legal guardian or establish a trust to manage the assets on behalf of the minor until they reach the age of majority.

If using a trust, appoint a trustee who will responsibly manage and distribute the assets for the benefit of the minor. The trustee can be the same person as the legal guardian or a separate individual, depending on your preference.

Naming Special Needs and Other Life-Long Dependents as Beneficiaries

Naming special needs individuals and other life-long dependents as beneficiaries requires careful consideration to ensure their ongoing care and financial well-being. Choose a trustee who understands the unique needs of the individual and is capable of managing the trust responsibly. This may be a family member, friend, or professional trustee, depending on the circumstances.

It is also important to consider the impact of an inheritance on the individual’s eligibility for government assistance programs. Structuring the trust properly can help preserve these benefits while still providing for additional needs.

How Do Contingent and Primary Beneficiaries Work?

Naming beneficiaries for your life insurance policy involves a straightforward process. Reach out to your insurance company or financial institution that manages the life insurance policy. They can provide you with the necessary forms or direct you to an online portal where you can make beneficiary designations.

Submit the completed and signed form to the insurance company. This can usually be done by mailing the physical form or submitting it electronically through the provided online portal. Double-check the accuracy of the information provided. Ensure that names are spelled correctly, and all details are accurate. Mistakes in beneficiary information can lead to complications in the future.

In most instances, policyholders designate primary beneficiaries who will be the first in line to receive the death benefit. This could be a spouse, children, parents, or any other individual or entity of your choosing. Then designate contingent beneficiaries as backups in case the primary beneficiaries are unable to receive the benefits. This provides a clear succession plan and avoids complications if the primary beneficiaries predecease you.

An older gentleman engrossed in a captivating game of chess with a young grandchild, both wearing smiles of concentration


Why Primary and Contingent Beneficiary Designations Matter

Designating both primary and contingent beneficiaries helps avoid delays and potential legal complications in the distribution of the death benefit. In the absence of contingent beneficiaries, the process may become more complicated if the primary beneficiary cannot receive the proceeds. Moreover, if relationships change, or if the primary beneficiary’s circumstances change, the contingent beneficiary designation can adapt to reflect the policyholder’s current intentions.

Why Do I Need to Name a Backup Beneficiary?

Choosing contingent beneficiaries for assets that skip probate is a strategic approach to estate planning, providing a clear succession plan and avoiding delays associated with probate. Assets that skip probate are those that transfer directly to beneficiaries outside of the probate process, which can lead to quicker and more efficient distribution.

Some policies have provisions addressing simultaneous death scenarios, where the policyholder and primary beneficiary die within a short period. Contingent beneficiaries help address such situations by specifying who should receive the death benefit if primary beneficiaries cannot be determined.

What Happens if You Don't Name Contingent Beneficiaries for Your Assets?

If you don’t name contingent beneficiaries for your assets, it can lead to complications and uncertainties in the distribution of your assets, especially if the primary beneficiary dies prematurely or is unable to inherit or disclaim the assets.

In cases where the policyholder designates only a primary beneficiary and that individual is unable to receive the benefit at the time of the policyholder’s death, the policy might become subject to the laws of intestacy. This means that the state laws determine the distribution of assets, which may not align with the policyholder’s wishes.

The Importance of Updating Primary Beneficiaries

Updating primary beneficiaries allows you to reflect changes in your family structure, such as marriages, divorces, births, or deaths, ensuring that your assets go to the intended individuals. Regular reviews and updates to beneficiary designations ensure that your choices align with your evolving circumstances and intentions. Making updates to beneficiary designations will help ensure that the paperwork reflects your current situation and relationships with the people around you.

How to Change Beneficiaries

  • Request a beneficiary change form from your insurance provider and fill it out accurately and completely. Provide the details of the new beneficiaries, including their names, addresses, and the percentage of the benefit each should receive.
  • If the policy has multiple beneficiaries, clearly specify the percentage or share each beneficiary should receive.
  • In some cases, the insurance company or financial institution may require additional documentation to process the beneficiary change. This could include proof of identification for the policyholder and, in certain situations, consent from the existing beneficiaries.
  • Be aware that some policies, especially employer-sponsored retirement plans, may have restrictions on changing beneficiaries outside of specific enrollment periods or events.
  • Consult with legal and financial professionals if you have complex estate planning goals or if there are legal considerations, such as spousal consent requirements.

Get Comprehensive Insurance Today

CTI provides information on insurance policies for commercial truckers. Get a truck insurance quote from our agents and gain access to some of the best deals in the industry. We work with multiple carriers to help you get competitive rates. To ensure your satisfaction, we offer continual support to address any concerns that may arise with your policy.